European Justice ruled against Spanish Inheritance Tax

In recent declarations raised, European courts declared that Spanish Inheritance and Donation Tax partly breaks European Union regulations. Luxembourg Court ruled on 3rd of September 2014 that this tax, a tax whose management has been transferred from central Spanish government to the jurisdictions of Autonomic governments, breaks EU ruling as it forces those citizens residing in other EU countries to pay a higher amount for it. Most Spanish Autonomic tax authorities offer tax relief only to individuals residing in their own jurisdiction. Therefore, EU citizens that are not resident in Spain or property owners whose assets are outside the country are forced to pay the governmental rate, which is higher than the autonomic rate.

The EU Court of Justice (ECJ) consider that there is “no objective difference that may justify such difference” in the application of such regulations on resident or non-resident citizens, or on properties that are located within the Spanish territory or abroad. “Difference in treatment lead to discrimination,” is pointed out in this sentence.

European justice is in agreement with the European Executive, which brought the case to Court in 2012, and considers that there is a “restriction” on free circulation of capital, ‑one of the pillars in which the EU was built on‑, regardless the Autonomic authorities reduce or not the tax rates on an individual basis.

The sentence is mandatory for Spain, and no appeal can be filed against it. A spokesman for the Ministry of Finance and Public Administration admits the “complexity” involved in adapting it at present and states that the technicians are already discussing the possibilities for the correct application of the ruling.

Following this resolution, it would be possible to request the refund of the amount paid (or part of it) in the case of many heirs that paid the tax following these regulations, regulations that are now declared illegal. The procedure for requesting said funds will vary depending on the time that elapsed since this tax was paid, as it will be easier for those cases in which payment was carried out less than four years ago.

In case you are interested in getting further information on this issue or this resolution may be applicable in your particular case, please feel free to contact Manzanares Abogados for a detailed study of the situation.

Source: El País

Leave a comment

Blog

English speaking lawyers in Spain

What are your legal obligations as a foreigner in Spain?

When you move to a different country as a foreigner, whether temporarily or to become a long-term resident, there are … Read more

spain immigration lawyers most popular country for uk nationals eu

What is the most popular country for UK nationals living in the EU?

Here at Manzanares Lawyers, we have helped plenty of people from all around the world to become legal residents in … Read more

non resident tax spain remote workers

How much tax do remote workers have to pay in Spain?

Ever since digital nomad visas were announced in Spain to attract remote workers, one of the main proposed incentives was … Read more

non resident tax Spain

The best cities in Spain – and the world – for expats

Moving to a different country is sure to be a big upheaval for anyone, but it can also be incredibly … Read more

Do you have to pay tax in Spain as a non-tax resident if you don't work?

Do you have to pay tax in Spain if you don’t work?

Just like residents in most countries around the world, residents in Spain have to pay taxes to the Spanish government … Read more

non-resident tax Spain IBI surcharge

What is the ‘empty property tax’ in Spain?

With many homes in Spain standing vacant and access to affordable housing being a key social issue, the Spanish government … Read more

ETIAS non-resident Spain

How will the ETIAS affect foreigners who own property in Spain?

The EU is planning to implement new IT systems for better monitoring of travel within the Schengen Area, meaning non-EU … Read more

non resident tax Spain

What is the Special Tax Regime in Spain?

Maybe you have heard of Beckham’s Law before – a special Spanish tax law that was initially created for the … Read more

Spain immigration lawyers - top countries for expats and remote workers

Spain is a Top 2 country for expats and remote workers

Daydreaming about starting a new life somewhere welcoming and sunny? Whether you want to pursue training or education you can’t … Read more

difference between an NIE and TIE

What’s the difference between an NIE and TIE card?

If you’re planning to move to Spain and stay for more than 90 days, you’re going to need to register … Read more

IBI tax Spain

IBI: Who has to pay property tax in Spain?

When buying property or earning income in any country, it’s vital to know about tax liabilities, whether you’re counted as … Read more

How to file 2022 tax returns in Spain

The annual campaign for income tax returns has begun in Spain, with 11th April 2023 marking the start of the … Read more

Spain visa

What happens if you stay in Spain for more than 90 days?

Spain is one of the most popular destinations for visitors from around the world, with over 100 million people visiting … Read more

Spanish wealth tax

Do non-residents have to pay Wealth Tax in Spain?

Many foreigners are unsure about whether or not they have to pay income tax or property tax in Spain, especially … Read more

digital nomad visa tax benefits

What are the tax benefits of Spain’s digital nomad visa?

The Spanish government has teased the introduction of a ‘digital nomad visa’ for over a year as part of the … Read more

spain immigration reform 2022

How did Spanish immigration laws change in 2022?

Obtaining the right permits to live, work, and study in Spain has been a slow and complicated ordeal for many … Read more

popular places foreigner Spanish real estate investment

Popular places for foreigners to invest in Spanish real estate in 2022

More foreigners than ever are buying homes in Spain, fuelling consistent growth in the Spanish housing market. In the first … Read more

Spanish Golden Visas still a top choice for international investors in 2022

Since the programme launched in 2013, the Spanish Golden Visa has remained one of the top choices for residency by … Read more

Ibiza lawyers fines

7 Spanish laws you should know before going to Ibiza

Spanish fines you should know about before going to Ibiza The idyllic island of Ibiza draws millions of tourists, visitors, … Read more

Ibiza Spanish visa

Thinking about living in Ibiza as a digital nomad?

Moving to Ibiza as a digital nomad Working remotely wasn’t an entirely new concept, but when COVID-19 shut everything down … Read more

Spanish residence vs Spanish citizenship

Spanish Residency vs Spanish Citizenship

Spanish residency vs Spanish citizenship: What’s the difference? As you probably know, you don’t have to be a Spanish national … Read more

best places to live in Spain

16 of the best places to live in Spain

If you’ve been dreaming about moving to Spain, or even just buying a second home there to spend holidays in … Read more

Spanish Golden Visa guide

The dos and don’ts of getting a Spanish Golden Visa

For those with sufficient disposable income, the Spanish Golden Visa programme is a great option for gaining legal residency in … Read more

immigrate to Spain

7 reasons to immigrate to Spain

7 reasons to immigrate to Spain Who hasn’t dreamed about spending endless days in the sun, surrounded by beautiful nature … Read more

brexit spanish golden visa

Can Brits still buy holiday homes in Spain after Brexit?

Second homes & Golden Visas: Can Brits buy holiday homes in Spain after Brexit? When Britain officially left the European … Read more

Who inherits the most from Spanish inheritance law

Who inherits the most from Spanish inheritance law?

Of course, the subject of inheritance is one that many want to avoid, as after all, it is centred around … Read more

Why renegotiating your Spanish property might be necessary

Why renegotiating your Spanish property might be necessary

Do you feel like your financial position has changed significantly enough that you cannot keep on top of your current … Read more

How does Spanish inheritance tax differ from the UK

How does Spanish inheritance tax differ from the UK?

Inheritance is never a topic that people want to dwell on. But if you’re spending your retirement years in a … Read more

spanish lawyer that speaks your language

Why is it important to hire a lawyer that speaks your language?

We can imagine that the last thing you will want to encounter is important legal negotiations with someone who doesn’t … Read more

off-plan property in Spain

Buying an off-plan Spanish property: A risk worth taking?

Building your own off plan property in Spain is the dream of many, right? After all, the gorgeous weather, friendly … Read more

spanish housing regulations

What is important to know about Spanish housing regulations?

More and more people are coming to Manzanares Lawyers to learn about the laws on renting out property in Spain. … Read more

All you need to know about Spanish property conveyancing

All you need to know about Spanish property conveyancing

When purchasing a property in Spain for the first time, it is highly likely that you are going to want … Read more

why write a spanish will

Why should you make a Spanish Will?

The subject of making a will is one that many shy away from talking about and for good reason! No … Read more

LICENSES FOR NEW CONSTRUCTIONS INCREASED 10.4% IN FEBRUARY

LICENSES FOR NEW CONSTRUCTIONS INCREASED 10.4% IN FEBRUARY

SOURCE: SPANISH REAL ESTATE MAGAZINE 06/05/2019 Licenses for building new property increased 10.4% in February, when 9.168 licenses were granted … Read more

SALES ON NEW PROPERTY INCREASE ON 14.4% ON THE FIRST QUARTER

SALES ON NEW PROPERTY INCREASE ON 14.4% ON THE FIRST QUARTER

ON THE FIRST QUARTER OF THE YEAR, 133.989 UNITS WERE SOLD. TRANSACTIONS ON NEW PROPERTY INCREASED ON A 14.4% ANNUAL, … Read more

LUXURY HOTEL COMPANIES FOCUS ON THE COSTA DEL SOL

LUXURY HOTEL COMPANIES FOCUS ON THE COSTA DEL SOL

SOURCE: SPANISH REAL ESTATE MAGAZINE 07/05/2019 Four Seasons lands on the Mediterranean sea in the entrance of Marbella, hand in … Read more

Property prices increase for the first time in six years

Property prices increase for the first time in six years

According to the Second hand property sale price index (IPVVR in Spanish), which is produced by the Land Registry using … Read more

Spain Flag

“Spain is back”

JPMorgan states on its last report: “Spain is back”. The American company increases the 2014 GDP forecast for Spain, encouraging … Read more

Málaga airport hit last august a record in number of visitors

Málaga airport hit last august a record in number of visitors

For Malaga airport, last August was the month with the highest number of users of its history, with 1,680,707 passengers, … Read more

Spanish Golden Visa

Main benefits from recent “Golden Visa” in Spain

After Law 14/2013, dated 27th of September, went into force, a significant number of applications for “visa” or residency in Spain … Read more

European Justice ruled against Spanish Inheritance Tax

European Justice ruled against Spanish Inheritance Tax

In recent declarations raised, European courts declared that Spanish Inheritance and Donation Tax partly breaks European Union regulations. Luxembourg Court ruled on 3rd of September 2014 that this … Read more

Blog
Call Now Button